Return to newsletters
In Negotiations, Size Doesn’t Equal Power. Your BATNA Does

In Negotiations, Size Doesn’t Equal Power. Your BATNA Does

Ever stared up at a corporate “giant” and felt your knees wobble?

  • Relax: bulk doesn’t buy bargaining power; alternatives do.

  • If the other side can’t walk away cleanly, they’re the frail one, no matter how many zeros they post on the Fortune list. 

The bottle-neck story 

A few years back, a long-time client (for confidentiality reasons, we will refer to him as PackCo) supplied plastic bottles to PepsiCo, one of the three beverage titans in the U.S.

An email arrived: 

“We’re rolling out a 5 % cost-reduction program. Please revise pricing accordingly.” 

Classic conditioning move. One-way broadcast, no dialogue, designed to anchor the conversation before it even starts. 

Inside PackCo: panic.

  • PepsiCo bought 90 % of its plant’s volume.

  • A 5 % price cut would sink EBITDA below zero; losing the account meant shuttering the factory.

  • The account team felt powerless.

  • Why? Because they only inspected their downside. 

So we asked the one question every negotiator should tattoo on their forearm: 

“What could the other side do if they can’t reach an agreement with you?” 

PackCo’s quick‐fire answers: 

  1. Capacity scramble – PepsiCo would need three suppliers to match PackCo’s volume mix. 

  2. Re-qualification chaos – every new bottle spec triggers line stoppages, test runs, recalibrations. 

  3. Freight folly – shipping bottles is shipping air; PackCo’s plant sat next door, rivals were states away. 

  4. False economy – none of those rivals were 5 % cheaper anyway. 

In short, PepsiCo’s “alternative” was a logistical migraine that blew their cost-saving narrative to pieces.

Once PackCo grasped that PepsiCo’s BATNA was lousy, they reversed the script: raised prices, protected margins, and PepsiCo paid without a squeak. 

Power ≠ size. Power = quality of BATNA 

Harvard’s PON research hammers this point: the side least dependent on the deal wields the leverage.

Two common blunders spring from hazy BATNA thinking, and both are deadly: 

163655 1748277415337.png
 

PackCo had “BATNA Deflation” syndrome. PepsiCo knew PackCo’s volume exposure and weaponised anchoring to feed that fear.

The cure was a cold-eyed BATNA audit of both sides. 

 

Four PON-backed moves to keep you grounded 

  1. Map Dual BATNAs 
    Draft two columns: Our Alternatives / Their Alternatives. Be brutally candid. If you can’t name three concrete fallback options, you don’t have them… yet. 
    Harvard’s PON tip: “Decision-tree” your scenarios: probability × value. A weak-but-likely Plan B can trump a strong-but-implausible fantasy. 

  2. Reality-Test Their BATNA 
    Ask “what would have to be true?” for their fallback to work. (Multiple suppliers? Regulatory sign-off? Time?) Then surface those hidden costs in conversation, peeling their power façade without overt threats. 

  3. Upgrade Your BATNA, Loudly but Politely 
    Even incremental moves (pilot projects with rival buyers, small-batch diversification) boost confidence, and confidence is contagious. Signal those upgrades; secrecy breeds assumptions, not leverage. 

  4. Anchor Back with Value, Not Price 
    Conditioning emails toss out single-number anchors. Counter-anchor by surfacing total cost of ownership, switching costs, brand risk, ESG scores, whatever widens the financial lens and shrinks their discount narrative. (PON calls this “redefining the pie.”) 

 

From theory to street smarts 

Next time that Goliath bangs on your door: 

  1. Pause the adrenaline. The first brain chemical released in a surprise demand is cortisol, not logic. 

  2. Run the BATNA X-ray (both sides). Scribble, don’t theorise. 

  3. Pressure-test the numbers.  Ask yourself, “How expensive is their cheapest alternative, actually?” 

  4. Craft a confident reply. “Happy to explore efficiencies. Before we discuss price, let’s lay out the true cost drivers…” 

  5. Be ready to say “No.” A credible exit is the cheapest source of power you’ll ever own. 

 

Bottom line 

Power lives in alternatives, not in brand heft, market share, or who emailed first.

  • Get obsessed with improving your Plan B and poking holes in theirs.

  • Do that, and even the biggest players start to look, well, a little hollow. 

Return to newsletters